Pakistan's Helicopter Problem
- Please log in to reply
- PDF Elite Member
- 4,393 posts
Posted 19 July 2013 - 05:45 PM
Helicopters are also an important consideration in terms of the topographic scenario not only in the north but also to the east, where any future conflict with India requires conflicts across rivers and other natural barriers. In contrast to India's huge fleet of growing helicopters including now locally manufactured units, Pakistan has a long-term perceived need of maintaining a semblance of comparability.
One of the key features of the Pakistani helicopter fleet is the diversity of the helicopters available. These include AH-1s, IAR 330, Aerospatiale Alouettes, AS350, UH-1, Bell 412, 206 Jet Ranger, Mi-17s, Z-9s and more. This wide diversity of helicopters with often a small number of units of each type adds a great deal of maintenance and operational issues that adds both expense and consumes significant resources.
The attack helicopter presently in use is also ageing and rapidly losing its operational capability at a time it is needed the most. The AH-1s have been highly successful in FATA and Swat and their dwindling numbers is a serious cause of concern. Pakistan Army (PA) is presently looking at potential replacements including potentially the Z-10 and the Turkish T-129 but funds remain scarce and these deals seem far off. The point remains that even if such a deal goes through, PA will not be able to buy the quantities that the present operational conditions and the long term requirement vis-a-vis the topography in the North and the challenge from the East pose.
Perhaps the answer to this quandary is to replicate the JF-17 and Al-Khalid programs and build an equivalent helicopter plan. One possible solution is to look at importing blue-prints and know-how coupled with joint development. Such a solution could find a partner in China or Turkey. Yet another solution exists.
Given the geo-strategic situation, the US cannot be seen to contribute much post-2014 when their troops leave Afghanistan. Meanwhile, the new Iranian government is showing positive overtures to Pakistan. Iran produces UH-1 / AH-1 helicopters and has the blue prints and production line. While Iranian helicopters are of doubtful quality, if manufacturing of these can be obtained under the table, Pakistan could have an ideal platform to begin helicopter production at minimal cost. Utilizing better technology and higher quality machine tools, Pakistan would produced significantly higher quality aircraft. If technology partnerships can be made with South Africa, China and Turkey in terms of sub-systems and components, the AH-1s and UH-1s could be updated to a competitive offering.
In addition, given the huge market of AH-1s and UH-1s globally, this is one product that can be sold as replenishment, spares or even new procurement. It is after all, much easier to add an existing type rather than procure a new type which are often significantly more complex and costly. The present US AH-1 Super Cobras offered have also evolved significantly and are not equivalent to the original AH-1s so the path is clear to make a meaningful inroad into the international market.
It is often said that with every challenge comes an opportunity. The present challenge in FATA, the decades long war in Siachin, and the new threat posed by India with its wild procurement of advanced helicopters and local production may just be the challenge that can become an opportunity.
- Senior Members
- 8,694 posts
- Location:Parachinar, Pakistan
Posted 19 July 2013 - 09:09 PM
........ the Black Flags Army shall rise from Khurasan and commence its earth rumbling march toward Damishque. Any force that tries to come in its path, shall be destroyed with ruthless destruction. Awaiting, upon reaching Damishque, the safron and beads of pearls and the Black Turban that shall lead the Salah of Fajr .........
........ the stones and trees of Lud shall cry out to the Black Flags and tell them of the Munafiqs, Yahuds and Kuffar that are hiding behind them, to come and kill them. That day shall be the day of reckoning, the day of justice, the day when no power shall hold and unfair advantage. The battle shall be fought and won by way of faith ........
........ it shall be done, as it is said "Kun Faya Koon
By, Mujahid Hosein (son of Imran Hosein)
- Senior Members
- 2,960 posts
Posted 20 July 2013 - 03:11 PM
Given the success that PA has had with the AH-1 they should feel very comfortable replacing them with a similar sized attach heli like the WZ-19. It has similar characteristics but PA would be able to get it with more advanced weaponry such as the HJ-10 or AR-1 or the CM-502KG.
They can move to replace the utility choppers with Z-9s to give parts uniformity with the WZ-19 or easy maintenance and operation costs
Discuss production of Mi-17 with Russia as this is a rugged chopper that is comparable to most medium weight multipurpose choppers like the blackhawk...even though it is ugly as sin. Another option could be the Z-15 in the future.
- Full Members
- 347 posts
Posted 21 July 2013 - 01:02 PM
In addition to this, Pakistan Army Aviation could establish its own Rotary-Overhaul plant/s. This would allow PAA to achieve higher serviceability rates and would increase operational availability of all rotary assets.
Pakistan Army and PAF do have overhaul depots. PAF has an overhaul depot at PAF Faisal. Similarly, PAA has overhaul facilities for Puma, Alouette (being retired), Lama...the American helos such as Bell 412 and Cobra still have to be sent abroad for overhauls (but they are relatively new, especially the Bell 412's).
The need for sending these helis (Mi-17) abroad for overhaul is because of over utilization of the overhaul facilities due to WoT and other uses. Engines and transmission are sent to Ukraine for overhaul in any case.
- Full Members
- 277 posts
Posted 04 November 2013 - 05:05 PM
- Senior Members
- 6,708 posts
Posted 05 November 2013 - 02:42 PM
The down side is, brains and experts are fleeing Pakistan because they cant get jobs, or those who are settled overseas will not return because of social insecurity and will feel treated injustly by egoistic superior officers and officials.
Meaning, they will want their shares before this kind of project starts.
Financial Fundings, the workers have their personal expenditures to pay and live for, if they arent paid then they have to obviously find another job.
Therefore no skilled, specialized and innovative minded individual will do any job because they cant buy basic needs (if also taken exitpoll in Maslows Basic Law)
The commitment from above levelled officials is very vital and supportive for the workers to succeed a healthy project on the long run.
E.g. Rocket Sciences, jet engine technology, missile technology, sattelite technology, radar technology, wave and frequency technology, nuclear technology, all came to existance from Nazi Germany, Allied Forces against Nazi Germany before 1945, then the transition to the Cold War between Russia and usa, the West.
All dependant of one thing, strong political leadership and strategical military interests, combine these together then the result would be like american, Russian and Chinese military hardware of various types.
Something Pakistan must and have to learn, like when acquiring nuclear technology, JF17 Thunder project, joint Pak China project ventures, Khalid Tank project, making own guns, rifles, military hardware, which i personally think is less due to the no attention and focus from the Pakistani leadership.
Pakistan can make a. Lot of military toys, but it will take time and a healthier bugdet, nothing is free.
Which we naturally, logically and obviously all know that there arent any brave and corrupt-free political leaders will ever do favouring the country's strategical military hardware interests in the long run.
- Senior Members
- 6,596 posts
Posted 09 November 2013 - 07:54 PM
South African Rooivalk with its ATGM Mokopa of range ~10km is also a good option as PAf also gets missiles from South Africa. not dependant on hellfire ATGM unlike T-129 etc.
King-6, Bravo is Mission Complete, Send Black Window.
- Full Members
- 800 posts
Posted 11 November 2013 - 05:25 AM
Although I would prefer the Wz-10, the Turkish T-129 offer is on ideal terms for Pakistan because of the technology transfer offer. Turkey understands in order to have good export success they need additional production facilities of Kamra plus use in Pakistan's war on terror would be excellent PR for the T-129. The Chinese have a big domestic need for gunships so might not be able to provide helicopters on priority basis. The only reason why I see PA dragging on with the Ah-1 Cobras is because they might have been being maintained via coalition support funding from the US. Once thats over PA would be pressed to replace them ASAP.
There are two versions of the T-129
T129A EDH (Erken Duhul Helikopteri) T129A is the "combat support" version equipped with a 20 mm gatling gun and rounds and can carry 70 mm (2.75 in) rockets; nine T129As have been ordered. Six helicopters have been produced and delivered to the Turkish Army. The T129As are to be upgraded to the T129B standard later. T129B T129B is the "multi-role" version equipped with the leading edge electronic warfare systems. 51 helicopters are to be produced, with one to be used as a weapons testbed. The T129B is armed with a 20 mm gatling gun and can carry a payload of 8 UMTAS, 12 Roketsan CIRIT, and 2 AIM-92 Stinger missiles.
Pakistan should opt for the cheaper T-129A with Bakthar Shikan / TOW firing capability at the moment to replace Cobras 1:1. Turkey has stressed that the T-129 has the best operation costs for any gunship and since our immediate need is for there use against the TTP militants the basic version should be enough for PA. They could be upgraded to B standard later on for a more advance adversary.
For the transport fleet since Aerotron is blacklisted by PA for leaking sensitive information to the US, this rules out further US heli options. Pakistan should opt for more Mi-17s (Production expected to shift to China), AS 350s (as it has proven high altitute performance) and Z-9s (general purpose helicopter for PA).
1 user(s) are reading this topic
0 members, 1 guests, 0 anonymous users